SPECIESISM, CARNISM, AND OTHER CLICHÈS

schiaviSomeone, sometimes, to stand out, decides to coin a new word: there are those who – like me – mean to identify something new, while others want simply to describe something that already exist, attributing it a particular interpretation.

In recent years I have been associated, invited to speak about and requested several times in relation to some of these terms: in particular, “speciesism” and “carnism”. Both were coined – coincidentally – from psychologists, who intended to give a significant ideological behavior habitually used widely in Western society and that, in their opinion, would not be dictated by mere emulation, but by a genuine ideological inclination based on precise assumptions: in one case the superiority of the human species, in the other – it is not clear what is the assumption – the desire to eat meat.

But what is ideology? One definition is “the complex of theoretical and ideal for a party, a political, social, religious movement” (Encyclopedia Treccani). You can certainly say that the act ideologically oriented assumes preprocessing (the creation or accession ideology), a critical time (is such conduct in conformity with the ideology?), execution ( if it conforms to the ideology) or abstention (if it is contrary to the ideology).

The Nazi movement was based on a racist ideology, since – leaving the other prerogatives – it based a discrimination on race: the “races” being discriminated against were not random, generic, or all of those other than the “Aryan race”; there were strict rules and hierarchies in discrimination, and some had to be physically removed (Jews, Gypsies, etc.)., others subservient (Slavic), and others purified (English), and so on.

In Nazi thought Jews were not deprived of rights in order to exploit them, but because they were considered impure, harmful and detestable: their social exclusion or physical elimination was not a result of other interests and was not a mean, but the true end.

The Africans imported as slaves in America were not for ideological reasons: no moral duties were in any case implied, but much more simply, as in all of human history, it was the strong exploiting the weak. So was the Romans who brought in chains enemies to make them slaves of Rome, so for Africans, like Native Americans and countless cases more or less known to history (and to contemporary chronicles).

Wanting to make a comparison with the above, I can not see any analogy between the ideological act of Nazi racism and that of eating meat or take advantage of the animals, which are simply the manifestation of that principle innate in most of us so if something makes us comfortable and does not require sacrifice, then we have every right to do so.

The fact that the defenses of established habits such as eating meat or exploit non-humans relate to the hypocrisy of trivial or self-defense mechanisms, or of cultural and social clichés, can not push any serious researcher to consider them as really fundamental ideological systems certain behaviors.

Apart from the fact that “carnism” simply represents a specification of “speciesism” and that, therefore, it is not even an expression with any conceptual autonomy, both expressions appear or the result of a far-fetched ingenuity – consisting of taking for true and founding the “justifications” for those who exploit non-human – or a simple maneuver of self-marketing aims to promote themselves as authors.

The danger inherent in accepting similar thesis is precisely to create and disseminate the same ideology that does not actually exist… but now it exists thanks to Ryder and Joy! Today anyone can call a plant ideological justification of the exploitation of non-human on his part: the system set up by two Animal Rights Advocate! Today we can feed even more division, mental, and therefore also material, between “us” and “others”, labeling as “speciesist” those beyond the barricade and we, well, like “anti-speciesist”. Luckily I have not heard of “anticarnists”, but the definition is so shaky that it would be difficult to understand “antiwhat” one should be.

Dear Richard Ryder and Melanie Joy, loved ones and all their fans: let us face the reality and we acknowledge that, quite simply, we live in a part of the world known as “Western society” and with her habits, lifestyles and beliefs. We note that there is no “jeansism” at the base of the fact that we use the jeans and the Middle East no, no “televisionism” that impels us to watch tv on ideological grounds, nor “tiesm” that leads us to wear that useless tinsel: it is simply habits of established and widely inspired by the society not for ideology but as a simple habit.

If you want to fight against the windmills, even going so far to create yourself those enemies who will then, go ahead. But do it without the Eusebism, that was not intended as an empty term to say something that was already there, but as a word carefully chosen to represent a new thought and free from any influence, suggestion or model, offering the parameters with which to relate not only to a species or race, but all that exists: otherwise, in 10 years, 100 years, 1000 years, we will still be here to split hairs in four defenseless, to ascertain which species of clam is worthy protection, which is the QI minimum for access to a profession, which is the encoding DNA, enabling us to become politicians, etc.