FRUITARIAN ETHICS VS. VEGAN ETHICS

We often hear blame for vegetarians / vegans to be the exterminators of plants, and I ‘ve read (several times) wit “save a plant: kill a vegan”, which is associated with the – this time serious – consideration against vegans : “Even the plants suffer“.

It is not my intention to dwell on the scientific depth of the matter, is not to intrude into matters of competence of others , and because all things considered irrelevant from the eusebist perspective: suffice it to say that between animals (human and non-human) and plant there are obvious differences that as well as suggesting a different perception of suffering, show that it is impossible to practice certain special forms to plants. A plant can not be milked and forced into tight spaces where it is subject to foot traffic, and attacks from other plants, or dragged, pushed and carried out in slaughterhouses dripping blood, screams and smells of his fellows that have preceded it .

Resign themselves to cause and / or take advantage of every possible evil against anyone who is not the most ethical solution , but evidently it is the most comfortable .

Then there is the detail that no one considers, in advocating their cause: the production of “food” animal-derived involves the use of ten times that amount in vegetables, with which they are in fact fed animals.

To say that people who eat a salad slaughters plants, while the consumer of a steak respects the plant life would be like if the one who drops a nuclear bomb on a city calls “killer” the soldier who fired a rifle shot at the enemy .

While far from disinterested and objective observation you can still make a profitable ethical reflection: many argue the ethical duty of veganism on the basis of respect for the animals, for the environment and for people, stressing that the ‘ breeding causes:

– Over-exploitation of environmental resources ;

– Pollution ;

– Damage to health as unnatural nourishment for man ;

– Economic and social inequality ;

– World hunger.

It is curious to note that the above is absolutely true, but it would in all respects even if you should compare the vegan diet to that fruitarian , because the environmental impact of agriculture, including felling of forests, use of pesticides, genetic engineering, fertilizers more or less natural and depletion of the earth’s resources resulting from intensive farming, is devastating.

There is talk of agricultural desertification as the phenomenon that derives from the bondage of the total land cultivated fields, with the removal of all forms of plant life different from specific cultures, which, in turn, carried out in an intensive way, deprive the earth of the elements that make it fertile and that are artificially added: for this reason the wild plants have proved extraordinarily richer from the nutritional point of view of those grown.

But it is also true that man is not born carnivorous, but much less farmer and, indeed, began to hunt before that to cultivate.

Finally, there is the question of the rights of non-human animals: eating them do not respect the right to life, but depriving them of the habitat to make crops (agricultural and deserts) may not infringe their right to access resources the planet that we all share? Does not prevent them from even coming to existence, to reproduce, to perpetuate their species, to move freely?

And what about all the animals and insects overwhelmed and killed by farm machinery, pesticides, and by the numerous interventions in the fields? Besides, even exterminate an animal species competitor in access to resources is hardly a form of antispeciesism or unconditional respect.

Many are sensitive to the exploitation of nonhuman animals, care about the origin of cosmetics or clothing , so are not even incidentally connected with animal suffering, and yet no one asks how many species have disappeared as a result of agricultural use that has allowed bring to the table a vegetable .

In short, even without considering the merits of the matter “plant life”, it is enough to properly develop the arguments underlying the veganism to realize that their effective realization lies in the choice fruitarian, on pain of inconsistency with respect to the premises .

With these thoughts I want to emphasize two things: i) the goal indicated by the ideal of respect is the fruitarian; ii ) is always worth recalling that one can not demand total purity, nor be afraid by its absence … on the contrary, there is always space for growth and increased awareness.

(photo credit: http://static.panoramio.com/photos/large/1683104.jpg)