One of the messages that the front pro-vegetarianism is spreading is that people who love (non-human) animals do not have to eat them. True. But the love for them is not a necessary condition to abstain from killing (the question of what to do once killed, such as eat, wear or use them as a trophy, is irrelevant ), but only one of the sufficient conditions .
It is certain that anyone who loves someone else can not wanting evil, nor his death: for all those who profess to be animal lovers, being surrounded by dogs and cats, it is essential also to convey this message, which is that it is not “love”, but simple affection towards “some” creatures.
One can love human beings and hate others: the simple fact that one loves the relatives does not make everyone a philanthropist or a benefactor of all humanity, and indeed, in hindsight just who has the most at heart the interests of a single group is likely to affirm even if this means the abuse of the interests of others.
I am reminded of the famous exemption of “necessity” of those who, having chosen the vegan diet, use other animals to feed their dogs or cats, claiming a moral duty to respect the nature of the latter, not imposing undue dietary modifications. So as not to distort their friends, they prefer to kill strangers: for some strange reasons, in short, we do not believe in the right to impose a particular nutritional use a dog, but we consider correct to kill a cow to feed him .
To all these people is undoubtedly appropriate (I dare to say necessary) to clarify that the concept of love does not admit exploitation, damage, murder: the unconditional love is a feeling that has nothing to do with the pleasure or profit.
One doesn’t love animals just because enjoys the company of a dog, or because there was a cat who purred, standing in his arms: love is something more than the respect which, therefore, presupposes, but goes far beyond it.
But if there is not even the minimum respect for the right to life of others, how could you ever say to love an entire category of individuals?
Once clarified that the message “if you love them, you do not eat them” is useful, I would like to emphasize that it also has significant flaws that, in my opinion, limit the shareability.
In stating that it is a crime to kill another human being, none of us would ever dream of appealing to the feelings of love for all humanity, nor to suggest that only those who have at heart the welfare of their fellows should refrain from killing.
I wonder how effective and practical application would have the prohibition of killing human beings, if it was based solely on the feeling of love, particularly as we intend it today, that is, limited and selective, if not just exclusive .
Love, as we said, is a supreme feeling that can distinguish extreme and supererogatory acts, as to sacrifice themselves for beloved ones and prefer to suffer harm rather than causing it, or let it happen. All this is not necessary if it is simply to respect the fundamental right to life of others; then suggest that IF (and only if) we love the non-human, THEN we should not eat them, it seems to me misleading, because it implies that they do not enjoy a right to life to our peers, but merely that should appeal to our good heart and good will, to enjoy this grace.
Coming to the corollary of the statement “if you love them do not eat them”, it also implies the opposite: “if you do not love them, you can eat them”.
The application of the logical principle adopted can’t be one-sided and, therefore, if one attempts to derive a rule from a premise, the inversion of the second can only lead to the inversion of the first.
I don’t think that it is possible to induce all to love the non-humans, but frankly I don’t even think that it is desirable: it would mean endorsing the (wrong) idea that only those who deserve respect and love that only those we love deserve respect, whereas it can not be, because if it were, it would mean that we are not taking note of real rights of others, but that we are simply protecting arbitrarily something we care about.
The conclusion? Even if you do not eat them you love them.
(photo credit: http://humansarefree.com/2013/08/beautiful-island-of-swimming-pigs.html)