E. Tell me, then, Oh Altar, what is this love that gives to the human species so much to talk about, to struggle, to suffer, to write, to dissert, to invents music, poetry, and every other kind of imagination and creation that they call art?
A. Oh Enar this might be the most troubled question ever faced by humans. And you are asking that me, not even a part of the humankind, but just a curious spectator.
E. This, my dear Altar, is what makes you able to answer better than one of those who are actors, as they have not that distance, needed to really understand. But even if I fail, or your description won’t be accurate enough, I am still convinced that I could interrogate 10 or 100 or even 1000 different humans, obtaining from each of them a different tale of what love is. Please do not delay and satisfy my curiosity.
A. I’ll do what you are asking for. I’ll tell you about love what I could learn, but it is much easier to say what love is not, rather than what it actually is.
E. Explain, my Altar, what you mean.
A. Well, Enar, I could list endless prerogatives of what our humans call love, but perhaps you won’t be able to find any of them in that feeling, or in the actions made in its name. Suffice to say that in the name of love people have killed, as well as have given life, and everything else that is in the middle between these two extremes as far apart.
E. Who could have confused to such an extent that feeling, to take life in its name?
A. You see so much distance between those who take other’s life in the name of love, and who, instead, in the same name, sacrifices themselves for others; yet, if you think, maybe that there is not all that difference between the souls of those who chose one or the other: perhaps both were simply motivated by fear. Behold, the fear of losing a loved one is undoubtedly a constant that anyone who claims to have ever loved can report. But should we call this love, or selfishness, or fear?
E. So you think that one could kill for love?
A. No, on the contrary: I consider such a decision as one of the few absolute indices that one doesn’t know at all the meaning of this word, like many other behaviors that often are attributed to that feeling, but that have nothing to do with it.
E. Please, continue, and tell me what are these other behaviors you mention, that so often humans apparently confuse with love.
A. Thank you: finally a question that allows me to provide a satisfactory answer. The first thing that you will notice observing these humans and their idea of love will be its highly selective nature: it concerns, in fact, people who are connected for birth or sharing of life, or even those who for one reason or another appear more similar. So, you can observe, almost without exception, that the object of love are those born from the same parents, or those belonging to that group called family, and then to follow those who for one reason or another are considered similar: skin color, geographical origin, opinions, even individual choices such as preferences for politics or ideals or fetishes that represent them and which go under the name of flags.
E. But how can they misunderstand the concept of love, to equate it to what is actually mere similarity? Did those humans dedicated so many efforts and thoughts to that misunderstanding?
A. It is partly so, but I must tell you that most of them concern that kind of love that humans consider unique, and that binds them to another person only. Again, though, I have observed many contradictions.
E. Please do not save words explaining me all of that.
A. All the words that we know may not be enough, but I will try to describe some examples of contradictions around the so called romantic love, such as this particular case is generally defined. There are at least three gross confusion or misunderstandings:
1) possession,
2) need,
3) emulation.
Many, apparently, consider their loved ones as some sort of object, just a little more special than other items. They identify love solely or principally as the amount of control that you can exert on the lives and choices of others. Similarly, they may feel unloved if their partners does not show as many aspirations, such as morbid jealousy or interference with their choices
In addition to possession, one of the most common misconceptions about love is the need. It happens usually to find these words in many works dedicated to such a debated feeling: often, in fact, love proclamations begin or end with the expression “I need you”. It is actually pretty clear, in the expression itself, that it is nothing else, but the fulfillment of an irresistible urge, not unlike what is called addiction.
Finally, in the countless varieties of forms and expressions that represent this concept, you will soon realize many different degrees in its seriousness: there are those who ponder and carefully use this expression, while others seem to speak about love only because it is normal, and people around them do the same. I met so many lovers of love just as habit, or as they have seen it in the movies or read about it in a book, or for envy of their fellow men, or even just to join a mechanism which seems based on the naturalness of the system to which they belong.
E. Oh Altar, but what you’re talking about is much more than simple confusion: how can anyone, even based on a simple and reductive definition of love to which is accustomed, consider that the desire to own another human being, or the inability to give it up like any caprice, or even the imitation of those around him or a popular model? Even if our evolution path is different from their, I can hardly believe that so much our ancestors have been able to misunderstand, as it seems to do the ones you’re describing to me. Indeed, I can definitely say that our civilization has never so much distorted the concept of love, as humans do: they seem to have discovered little more than just a mere spark of it. According to you, one would think that in this arduous quest, not only the light is still far away, but even that the path might be oriented to darkness.
A. Indeed it is: whenever you cause suffering deliberately, or prevail over another, or you feel entitled to exploit those who you do not love to help your loved ones, that light seems to fade and so the hope of find the true meaning of that concept.
E. Yet there must be some hope: someone who has been able to transcend the most immanent instincts, the desire to emulate and all those conditions and restrictions you were talking about, to encompass something broader.
A. There are many reasons why the human concept of love cannot be truly unconditional, and, therefore, true love: from education to competition from ego nourishment and individual ambitions at the expense of others or the community, to the cultivation of differences as discriminating factors. I mean, how could someone who knows the true meaning of love, rejoice in the death of others? Yet this is natural among humans, and, indeed, the more they feel connected to someone, the more easily they are willing to cause harm or death to those who harmed their loved ones.
E. Of course, if these individuals that you describe are so prone to pander to their own pleasure and to defend it with such dedication, it is hardly surprising that both cultivate a desire for revenge for those considering aggressors of their loved ones: after all, in so doing, they just react certainly not in a disinterested way, but simply meaning to hurt as a prevention against being injured. So this would be their concept of love? Grow what satisfies them and fight what annoy them?
A. Unfortunately, I think that you understand exactly the main mistake that prevents humans to evolve in the knowledge of what really love is. Not infrequently it happens to hear about love and hate as the two sides of the same coin, or even to observe how two people, who have promised love one to each other, can then hate, fight and get each other sick.
E. Oh Altar, at this point allow me to express a doubt about the correctness of what you are telling: I can understand the many contradictions and the many misunderstandings of this sort, but if it was true that only one of them could ever want to causing hurt someone who had previously claimed to love, then all others should be clear that love cannot turn into hatred, and indeed, cannot be transformed at all.
A. See, Enar, if they were able to accomplish what you described, they would have understood the unconditional nature of love: they would know, namely, that it is not about giving something to receive. The same way they would know that, if that feeling was pure, so as not begin because reciprocated, even when it would not reciprocated. They would love so those who hate them, as those who love him, and equally those who do not share their thinking, and those who share it. It would, in short, understood that love does not begin and end, but it just is.
E. But you said that these humans, even with all their limitations, are able to understand the abstract and immaterial nature of love: how can, therefore, they give it boundaries in space or in time, which by nature and definition only concern what is material?
A. I no longer have much to teach you about the human consideration of love, as you have just described one of the greatest paradoxes that characterize it. The vagaries come and go, like utility or fulfillment: all this, which is ephemeral, often goes under the name of love. And it is that the reason why, once that pleasure, utility or return end, the so called love gives way to that other side of the coin called hate. Except that Love has no other faces that love, just as hate is always hate. Moreover, although it could be disguised as love, the desire to own or use others is still a typical characteristic of hatred, because you sacrifice other people’s good in favor of your own.
E. Yet humans do a lot of talk about love, especially in those disinterested gestures they see the sacrifice of one in favor of those he loves.
A. If you look more closely, or Enar, you will see that even in those gestures there is interest: who sacrifices himself for not seeing someone suffering he cares about, it is because he knows that doing so will avoid their suffering. You will have easy test reasoning in reverse: how many would sacrifice themselves to save someone’s pain which are not related? Here, how many would be able to withstand bad to prevent other, no matter that these consider them friends or enemies, giving him love or indifference or even hatred? Surely among them, if ever there were, you will find those closest to understand the true meaning of love.
E. So you’re telling me that for human love is actually to discriminate, to use other people to satisfy needs, and even justify violent acts in this way, retaliatory or even hatred. They do not see, perhaps, impossible to reconcile things between them so different and even opposite? Possible that nobody has been able take the concept of love out of space, time and selfishness constraints?
A. Do not get me wrong: I’d be lying if I assert that no one has tried to transcend the limits that you described. Even though, I could tell you with certainty that someone succeeded. See well that respect and love, in their purest sense (and in this sense is quite different from the one in use among humans), cannot be separated. Both can only be unconditional, or not be at all. However, even many of those who are committed to seek the deeper meaning of love often ended up cultivating their own discrimination, for example calling one a “person”, another “non-person”, and considering the latter as an item. They also decided, often, to exclude from love (and then from respect) those who in their eyes looked different, maybe because they are made of wood and leaves, or minerals, instead of flesh and bone. For example, they considered who breathes more important than who does not, arrogating to dispose of the latter. I can hardly think of anyone in particular being able to really embrace and fully understand the connection of all things, so as to realize that just love, like respect, cannot be selective or conditional.
E. Thank you for sharing with me your observations and your thoughts. Let me ask you one more thing: do you think there is no chance that this species realizes the ultimate meaning of what they call love?
A. It may seem hard to believe, given what I’ve just described to you, but in reality everything is an experience, needed to gain awareness. While humans, about love, now seem in search for a path through the forest in the dark of a moonless and starless night, it is true that from their mistakes will arise the seed of awareness. After all we too have been like them, and if not so, certainly we got lost several times, and only after traveling the wrong paths we were able to find the right one.
E. I would like to share your thought, and I have so much respect to believe that it cannot be unfounded; however, I wonder how many of their years will be needed to ensure that this research bears fruit.
A. This, in all honesty, I cannot say: they will still make a lot of experiences, probably even more complex than the old ones. How many will be needed, and how much of their time this will take, it is unknown to us who are mere observers: the fate of the actors of this show is entirely in their hands, and understanding this, perhaps, will be already the turning point needed.
