NERONE VS. GANDHI: WHO WOULD YOU THROW FROM THE TOWER? DEFINITELY THE WRONG ONE

E0702 KLENZE 9463

Nero the villain, the madman, the pyromaniac of Rome.

Gandhi the saint, the enlightened one, the wise one.

If they asked us to choose which of the two to throw from the tower, and who to save, the question would seem even rhetorical: to death the dictator, long live to the liberator!

But who said that Nero was a cruel pyromaniac? History (official). Which, moreover, also teaches us all about Gandhi. Almost.

Let’s take a step back: who decides what is the official truth, that is, what will then be counted as “history”? The winners, and, more generally, who holds the power.

It is not an unusual motto that “The story is made by the winners”. Yet knowing that, does not exempt us from constantly entrusting ourselves to that story, without hesitation. Without doubts. Uncritically.

Retracing the sources, and flying over folklore, unsuspected discoveries are made.

Nero, educated by the philosopher Seneca, was an enlightened and reforming emperor, who could count among his political choices such as:

– the monetary reform that privileged the denarius (the currency used by the urban plebeians), compared to the aureus (the currency used by the wealthy classes);

– the abolition of some secret procedures within the processes;

– setting limits on lawyers’ fees;

– the possibility of taking legal proceedings against the tax authorities;

– a tax reform project meant to abolish internal customs duties (detrimental to large landowners, beneficial to the less well off);

– closed the doors of the temple of Janus (god of war) and interrupted the military invasions;

– encouraged the arts and athletics.

But all those reforms and ideas contrasted with the dominant political and economic class, which, in turn, was also the one to which the literati belonged, that is, those who handed down history (Suetonius and Tacitus, above all). While the emperor was favoring the people, the rich began to do what everyday life has accustomed us, through press and televisions of part, which do nothing but muddy opponents, often creating, amplifying or transforming details and stories, to starting from private lives, that is from what, not being known directly to the public, can be easily reported without being easily denied.

Here is therefore born the myth of the emperor from unbridled sex life, devoted to vices and crowds. And, after all, are not they all mad, the dreamers, and the exponents of the avant-garde of thought?

And the fire, then? And persecutions to Christians as scapegoats?

Well, Nero, who physically was not even in Rome at the time of the fire, but in Anzio, immediately returned to the capital to personally participate in the rescue and extinguishing operations of the fire, housed the displaced persons in his imperial residence and financed part of the reconstruction with its own heritage.

After the fire Rome was not only rebuilt more beautiful, but also with the adoption of preventive criteria wanted by Nero, such as minimum distances, fire-resistant materials and the arrangement of fountains at regular intervals. And, above all, opposing the phenomenon that today we would call “building abusiveness”, which had been one of the main causes of the fire, or at least of the damage that ensued. And he did not persecute Christians for the fire.

Nero was not a saint, and he certainly was not exempt from excesses. He was, in part, a man of his time, and, in part, a sensitive and innovative spirit: these last two prerogatives earned him the proclamation of hostis publicus, the dismissal, and, finally, the damnatio memoriae senatoria.

What the memory of Nero was discredited is how, today, would have led to an enlightened ruler: unfortunately, however, any politician of that type is inexorably condemned to be opposed by the dominant system coevo.

And, then we come to Gandhi. Another politician, though in the collective imagination, represents without any doubt a figure of spiritual guidance. Yet Gandhi was a lawyer, first, and a politician, then.

Mahatma. Great soul. Pacifist, nonviolent reformer who had made a vow of poverty and abstention from sex.

Let’s therefore go over the salient stages of Gandhi’s political and human journey.

In 1893, the Indian lawyer went to South Africa, working with traders established there. In that same year the episode occurred (“provident misfortune”, would probably have called it Manzoni) that would have triggered the desire of Gandhi’s rebellion: the removal from the place in first class on the train, because of its color. This episode, more precisely, did not represent the awareness of a racial problem, but the disturbance of a lawyer belonging to the wealthy caste (Bania), which was seen to be equal to the treatment reserved for Indians who crowded that country as miners.

 

So much, so that not only Gandhi did not try to abolish caste, but, on the contrary, he was able to declare that precisely that system had guaranteed the elevation of the Indian nation, unlike Western societies. For this reason he was often challenged by the Dalits, whom he also addressed after having ascertained their essentiality for political purposes.

But let’s go back to South Africa. Here Gandhi, from the pages of the newspaper Indian Opinion (founded in 1904), thundered: “Ours is a continuous struggle against the degradation that is inflicted on us by Europeans, who want to degrade us to the level of raw Kaffir, whose occupation is hunting and whose only ambition is to collect a certain number of cattle to buy a wife, and then spend their lives in indolence and nudity “. Kaffir is what we would call today “racial insult” (as such, legally pursued in South Africa since 1976), used to describe the black population of South Africa, which Gandhi on several occasions turned negative (“barbaric and useless”). In the Zulu uprising against the British in 1906 Gandhi sided with the latter, stating that the resident Indian population would have to enlist among the English ranks to help repress the insurgency.

On the occasion of the execution of the Indian revolutionary Bhagat Singh, Gandhi said “I could have made the commutation of the sentence one of the terms of the agreement. It could not have been done. The working committee agreed with me that the conversion of the sentence could not be inserted as a prerequisite for the agreement “. And so he wrote to the Viceroy: “if the boys were to be hanged, it would be better to hang them before the session of the Congress (Karachi), rather than after”.

In 1932 Gandhi undertook a hunger strike that went down in history as a form of non-violent protest in favor of the abolition of the caste system. In fact, what Gandhi prevented was the attribution of autonomous parliamentary representation to the Dalits (the untouchables), which would have diminished the political relevance of his movement and favored that of the exponent Dalit, Ambedkar.

In the meantime, if in public he promoted non-violence, in private he showed obsessive jealousy towards his wife, coming to slap her and “teach her lesson” leaving her to look at her tears, after the beatings. Regarding the violent and possessive behavior towards his family, Harilal, son of Gandhi, wrote that he treated them “just as the circus trainer treats the animals under his responsibility”.

In the meantime, although he reserved similar possessive behaviors towards his wife, he still discusses whether or not he had a relationship with the German architect Hermann Kallenbach, whose intense correspondence was recently purchased by the Indian government. What is certain is that in his ashram he accompanied and slept with girls, strictly nude and very young, including his nephew’s wife, declaring that he used to use these “maids” to test his vow of celibacy, also through various practices, aimed at provoke him sexually.

In short, a pacifist Nero and a racist Gandhi. Who to throw down from the tower? Perhaps, now, the answer would no longer be just as obvious.

What reflections can we derive from all of the above? Many.

The first is that all that we know, nothing excluded, must be subjected to critical scrutiny, or, at least, we can not take for granted the truth or exactness.

The second is that there are no saints, but neither do we need saints. And there is no need for idols, models or guides. At the same time, anyone can take thoughts and actions into consideration, and even inspire them, without the need to include anyone in the category of “good” or “bad”.

We can and must separate what is “good” from what is “bad” in every person and in every situation (I use quotation marks, because the same categories of “good” and “bad” are illusory, and do not really underlie the differences that we bring you back).

At the same time, delegating to others (to anyone) the responsibilities that fall exclusively on us is a harmful act, which refers rather than allowing the process of awareness.

Moreover, even with regard to politics, the very fact that someone intends to present himself as a guide to others denotes his lack of awareness, and therefore implicitly the impossibility that this is what someone chooses to see us (a guide, in general).