PRAISE OF INCOHERENCE

incoherenceWe were always taught that the incoherence is regrettable, that those who are incoherent are wrong and that nothing can be learned from them: I maintain that this is not correct, and that – in fact – the incoherence can rise to real litmus test the validity of theories, concepts, ideas and ideals.

Let’s start with a trivial consideration: there is no absolute coherence in the human species. If it exists, they are marginal cases, or real bad faith: in general we are innately predisposed to recognize the error and the excess in the other instead of us, disregarding the noble precept of “do not do to others what you would not have done to you”.

Unfortunately, this process results and has historically led to political and philosophical thoughts closely related to the personal inclinations of thinkers and statesmen, as well as in adherence to them by the masses.

But if it is true that all of us are incoherent, then it is mathematically impossible that the “right” to match all our behaviors, so that they are all justified within a theory: if this were so, it would mean that whoever has made ​​it is 100% consistent, or that the theory is wrong.

People always say that the human being is limited, that his cognitive abilities and interpretation, as broad or expanded, are still subject to limitations and insurmountable objective: I do not think this is true, but I think rather that the present and past human beings are, but I also think that potentially each of us has within us the resources needed to rise without limit, except those that we ourselves impose.

So a human being, temporarily restricted, can’t do anything, but be related to his time, his habits, his prejudices, his inclinations: though it may work it’s unlikely to be able to totally get rid of them.

In short, if there is justification for everything we do, we should realize that we are the first perfect human to come to light, or – rather – that we are simply the nth affected by hypocrisy and believe to be right even though wrong.

The political fragmentation – of which, however, Italy is a prominent example in the world – reflects our condition: we are forced to look for balancing between opposing interests, since we can not reach, as individuals, a balance interior that allows us to work to the right, instead of to our interests.

An example, probably outdated but easy to understand: why there is a party that defends the interests of the workers and another who defends those of the “employers”? It is natural that the first’s instances, as well as those of the second, are not those of absolute right, but intended to benefit some at the expense of others. The proof? There are no employers in the party of the workers, or workers in that of employers, but if there were, then we would know with reasonable certainty that they are acting in accordance with a pure idea and not in compliance with an interest.

This is the reason because today, in a time characterized by limited human beings, unable to achieve the balance between opposing individually, the democratic comparison is not only a sterile form, but a necessity to ensure the most balanced possible choices.

Bobbio denied the existence of ideals of absolute good or right, saying that they are solely dependent on social context, which processes them: it is wrong by definition, because denying “absolutely” is something that is the opposite of relativism on which such conclusion is based. You can not say “everything is relative”, without incurring in a contradiction, which is identical in the negative formulation “nothing is absolute”: “all” and “nothing” are by definition absolute terms, total inclusion or exclusion, which is impossible in relativism.

To state, as Bobbio did, that there is not an absolute foundation of the right, only because in different historical periods mind had changed, is not a philosophical formulation, but simply a historical reconstruction: if everyone lies, does that mean there is no truth?

Similarly, none of us can be considered right if everything that professes coincides with what he practices in concrete, except that the latter is the perfect human being, as fully aware and perfectly consistent with his own awareness. But even if that were the case, people probably would not be able to recognize it as such, since it would judge with imperfect parameters, namely those related to personal inclinations, interests, prejudices and cultural substrata that prevent us from being perfect (in the above said meaning), and then – often – to recognize perfection.

When I formulated the principles of Eusebism I was not thinking about how I am today, or how the world is today, but using parameters and objective references, unrelated to subjectivity, and in many cases do not coincide with my own inclinations or behaviors. Those principles are absolute, such as relativizeable: criteria such as respect or balance do not say just “do this, do not do that”, but they impose and allow you to have a mindset adaptable to any context.

If I act on the basis of equilibrium, in the literal sense of the term, can not consider “right” to harass someone, or have more of these, or put me before to his interests, etc.

The same goes for respect: you can not respect someone / something by deciding according to your preference, but we must take into account the specificity of each individual, to enhance them. For example, I’m not disrespecting a stone if I do not greet it, but I could be disrespectful to a person in the same way: “suum cuique tribuere”, said Ulpian, that is “to recognize each his own”, not the same to all.

CONCLUSIONS

Any perfect ideal, compared to imperfect beings, can only be impractical, utopian: it is precisely for this reason that we must have the courage to go beyond all the clichés and subjective perspectives, having the courage not only to understand but also to indicate and promote fair as even and especially what you do not prefer, or maybe even you are able to do, but to which to aspire.

The ideal would be to know what is right and do it, but the road is long and the first step is to overcome denial and refuse self-persuasion or the hypocrisy that allows us to praise and promote only what we are willing to do, preventing us not only to change immediately, but – even worse – forever.

A contrariis, all the theories that could be called “populist”, socially shared and well accepted, are probably wrong, since only valid in the “here and now” that produced them, thus completely subjective and biased by prejudices because (today) are so limited in all fields of knowledge and being, only what agrees to questioning everything can have hope to rise, giving a final goal, and ( as such), which is hard to achieve.

Of course, this praise of incoherence is a priori and does not want to provide a pretext for moral wrongdoing, or to be good critics and bad agents, but quite the opposite. Have the courage to discover and admitted incoherent, as an essential step to initiate a transformation, before thinking, then to act: never an excuse for a posteriori justify not having acted like he had just said.

On the other hand “difficult” does not mean “impossible”, which leaves us with an unexpected message of optimism: the goal is distant, but we have everything needed to reach it, and it is inside of us.