Right, in human society, was created to govern the relationship between subsidiaries, between humans and humans: there weren’t any rules in relation to interspecies relationships, or, for example, between man and environment.
There is a fundamental discrepancy in the above: animals and the environment have always constituted objects for the exercise of certain of these rights, starting with the property.
The inclusion of a non-human animal, a field, or a tree, has never been formally sanctioned, but it has constantly taken for granted that everything not human is available to humans; in fact, everything different from the legislature was considered so, such as slaves, women, poor people, etc.
Today, the right has evolved on a basis quite different from the original ones: while the time of Hammurabi you could imagine how fundamental question essentially life and property, some millennia later blossomed and matured principles that are considered inalienable, with reference to the expression of personality free from restrictions, but were also introduced unusual subjects, such as non-human animals and the environment.
I believe that in this we are committing errors not dissimilar to those of old, hobbling around the idea, wrong by definition, that is the human right, anthropocentric, or, even worse, “legislator-centric”.
1. PURE AND POSITIVE LAW
There is a right, definite “positive”, that is the set of rules codified and incorporated into an order.
Legal positivism states that there is only positive law, that is enforceable in respect of which the individual can claim protection: everything else can be intended in various ways, but never falls within the definition of actual right.
This perspective has historically opposed that of the natural law, which states the existence of innate principles, of which the legislation would represent a mere formal transposition.
The intellectual aversion that the contemporary age has developed against the natural law has led to contradictions and gimmicks, such as that of the Italian Constitution, that in order to avoid the use of the expression “inherent rights” referred to the “unalienable rights”: where the first phrase refers to something that inevitably exists before the man so much as the legislature, the second – in the name of understatement – simply alludes to something that, pre-existing or not, it can not be denied, removed, disposed or alienated.
But why it can not be alienated, if there is no an innate principle? If everything is a source of the will of the legislature, who is citizen of its time and its socio-cultural context, why you should consider something intangible?
Stating that there are no absolute and innate principles, whose laws are mere transposition, contradicts the daily observation: anyone, even without studying the law, or to learn social customs, warns a deprivation, when suffers what he considers an injustice.
Anyone consider themselves injured if, without having done anything to others, are beaten, killed, deprived of liberty, etc.: it does not happen because there are laws, and people know that they have been violated, but because expectations are innate and pre-juridical.
If we are beaten without having beaten our aggressor, we feel “entitled” to retaliate on him, while the same does not happen if, after assaulting someone with a punch, he returns us: even though in the latter case the law gives us protection, we do not feel the same sense of revenge or injustice.
Most of the speculation around the right, like many others in the field of moral philosophy, in my opinion are unnecessary technicalities that complicate and empty of meaning the real issues, revealing sterile academic dissertations not usable in practice, nor to produce better rules.
We could even not call “right” what is not sanctioned by law, calling it “expectation” or “claim”, but that does not change the substance of the instances that are innate, not based on coding, and that do not cease even whether laws refuse to acknowledge them.
If there was nothing “natural”, it is unintelligible for what reason from the dawn of the laws to date certain contents have been constantly consolidated, and, when rejected, there had been revolutions, wars and fights to reassert them.
The history and the history of law teach that there has been an evolution towards a well-defined purpose, and that when some tried to reverse it, while resorting to the authority and force, he failed: whether, as dictated by legal positivism, there were no other right than that applied, why, for example, the dictatorships of the ‘900 would have disappeared under the pressure of freedom of expression instances? Why the associates should have considered wrong the laws forbidding them to challenge the rulers? The answer is obvious: there are innate aspirations that push in one direction and in one only, which requires training and the adaptation of standards that reflect.
2. UNIFY THE RIGHTS
The historic route of the rights was troubled and sometimes contradictory: I think that this is due to the inability of lawmakers to evade actually their own perspective, merely advocating the interests of their own or of their constituents / donors.
For this reason, laws recognize only those whose rights advocates take sufficient socio-political-economic power, representing an eternal tracking and balancing of interests, which in a democracy should be hypothetically represented in equal measure, but which are usually unbalanced in advance.
Here, then, that the legislature white enslaved blacks, the Aryan has banished the Jews, the man has degraded the woman, the human being has reified the non-human, etc..
For practical reasons, as well as philosophical, the only possible conclusion is that IF there are rights, then they must be up to all that is, or can not be recognized by anyone.
Of course we are not talking of civil law, which mostly comes from balancing of conflicting interests, and can be only of a conventional nature: unlike the criminal law, which is based on the innate moral conceptions.
The equalization of civil law to criminal law was also one of the tools that have allowed certain legal positivists, primarily Bobbio, to challenge the existence of natural law: the fact that some authors who supported natural rights had tried to derive such issues, as the right of inheritance, from the observation of nature does not mean that this is correct, or that a principle of nature is apparent in all human laws.
In short, I think that if in civil law it is widely shareable the assumption of legal positivism, it is equally true that this is not reflected in the criminal law provisions.
Given that we are discussing to define the limits of interference with others in relation to the fundamental aspects of existence, it is hard to consider the possible application of different criteria with regard to everything that exists: as it is not “fair” to terminate the life of a human being, it can not be interrupted even that of a non-human, a plant, or the flow of a river.
Human animals, not humans, plants, minerals, we are all united by a common origin and the elements that constitute us are in constant transformation from one state to another. What yesterday was gas in the air or mineral in the ground, tomorrow will be part of an animal body, and so on, but if I recognize the right to exist in an animal body, how can I deny it to the mineral or vegetable which, in turn, allowed it to exist?
Who sustains biocentrism forgets that: i) the definition of what is “live” is a convention, also subject to criticism and different theories, ii) not knowing the phenomenon which enables to what we consider “not alive” to become “live” is not a priori possible to say that an act on the first does not afflict the second, for example preventing it to come to existence, iii) everything that human science describes as “alive” can continue to carry out its biological functions only through the use and interaction with what is “not alive”.
What escapes in all the theories that are simply trying to extend rights, without actually giving up the subjective perspective, is that in a closed system, which on a large scale can be thought of the whole universe, we can not exclude a priori some elements, because all are interconnected and interdependent.
In philosophical terms, an attempt was made to limit (or, as in the minds of many, “to extend”) the ownership rights on the basis of the intellect, the ability to speak, to discernment, to feel pain, to carry out a process “vital”, but these should not be assumed to discriminate between those who can and who can not have rights, but – if anything – useful parameters to determine “what” rights recognized and to whom.
Who owns an intellect that makes him capable of complex thoughts will, for example, the right to express those thoughts, as well as who has the floor to speak, who can suffer in that it has not inflicted suffering, those who live not to be killed, who exists to continue to do so undisturbed, etc..
Different people, different characteristics, different needs = different rights.
3. CONCLUSIONS
It makes no sense to talk, distinguishing them, about human rights, animal rights, environment: everything that exists is interdependent and deny the ownership of rights to some, attributing it only to others, is a short-sighted and arbitrary discrimination, which – by syllogism – does not allow really to protect anyone, even those who consider themselves “worthy” of protection.
Nor is it necessary to speak of “right”, because the words are used only to invoke concepts based on conventions and it is wrong to stay attached with them, so much to dismiss the substantial problem, staying anchored to the form: protection, right, aspiration, expectation, etc. can be used and interpreted on, but the key issue is to implement those absolute moral principles and translate into behaviors and rules that guarantee them.
Should we define this system “right”, “law”, “protection”? I do not think that it is important, since the words have the meaning that people decide to give them: for this reason I find useless the endless treatises on the meaning of “right”, given that it is a concept devised by man, and therefore describable in any way.
By contrast, the moral “right” is something that must pre-exist to definitions and interpretations; otherwise it would be mere will (of peoples or individuals does not matter): this is where the rules must tend, in an impartial and objective, so that the author may appear to be a man as well as a woman, a human being, a nonhuman, etc.
As long as the regulatory principles will be inspired to favoritism towards the legislature, what is “right” can not find citizenship in laws.
As long as our concept of right will leave out the interconnection of everything that exists, it will be forced to grope in the darkness of prejudice and discrimination, as a mean of harassment of all, since there can be no respect for anyone if there is not for each.
I believe that a unified theory of law is the only possible solution to exit the crisis, cyclical and inevitable, in which human societies have paid and continue to pay due to the inability to deal fairly fundamental questions of existence .
Once we have understood and stated the principles to define and inscribe in them all that exists, as in physics, the right can be considered perfect, that is, in order to govern any relationship properly.
To exit from the perspective subjective Eusebism promotes the adoption of five basic principles, which characterize the moral theory, and therefore transferable to right:
1) RESPECT (observe what is other than itself)
2) OPPORTUNITY (repeatability by n subjects)
3) BALANCE (the interests involved must receive mutual satisfaction)
4) CIRCULARITY (first law of thermodynamics, nothing is created, nothing is lost: everything turns)
5) NON-INTERFERENCE (not to interfere with the existence, evolution or the survival of what is other than itself)
In concrete terms, the unification of right can take place through a reformulation of the rules designed to punish all human conduct detrimental not only (directly) to other humans, and giving up the notion that the legislature, or the group that they represent, can have arbitrarily everything else is on his / her group.
The scope of such a change is so radical that today it is hard to imagine the practical application and it is clear that it will require a long transition for the social values to evolve to such an extent as to be fully applicable to such a regulatory system; however, we should not be discouraged by the complexity and length of time that will be needed to fully realize the change: on the contrary it is necessary to focus on the importance of begin it.
The only question that arises is whether, having reached a level of awareness that high, the very existence of the law will actually have meaning and utility, considered that the number of laws is inversely proportional to the evolution of a society.
photo credit: http://www.globaloneness2013.org/event/science-of-interconnection/
